The challenge coin versus belt buckle choice usually depends on headcount. A challenge coin is a low-cost piece made in volume and handed out widely. A belt buckle is worn, made in small numbers, and given to a limited group. Units that order both often give coins to many and buckles to a handful.
One Ship, Two Pieces
The USS Patrick Gallagher (DDG-127) has both a challenge coin and this belt buckle. This Navy belt buckle includes these features:
- Shape and finish. A gold-tone rectangle with curved ends.
- Center window. An oval window frames the destroyer at sea.
- Background. A navy field of white stars, with green shamrocks.
- Top ribbon. Reads Be Brave Be Bold above the ship.
- Bottom ribbon. Shows the ship’s name below the ship.
- Corners. Celtic knots mark each corner.
- Sides. A chain pattern runs down both sides.
- Color. The navy field, stars, waves and shamrocks are filled with color. The ship, ribbons and border stay in metal.
- Reverse. The back is engraved.
The ribbon and chain pattern are often seen in Navy insignia. The ship is named for Marine Corps Corporal Patrick Gallagher, who was born in County Mayo, Ireland, and served in the Vietnam War. The Celtic knots in the corners likely nod to his Irish roots.
The ship’s challenge coin is oval with a chiefs’ mess design, so you can compare its artwork with this buckle’s.
How the Two Formats Differ
Four differences matter most:
- Cost per piece. A buckle often costs several times what a coin does.
- Quantity. Coins suit large groups. Buckles suit a few recipients, such as a wardroom or a chiefs’ mess. Buckles also follow their own belt buckle minimum order, separate from the coin minimum.
- What happens to it. A coin usually ends up in a drawer, a shadow box or a pocket. A buckle is worn, so people outside the unit can see it, and it takes more wear.
- Artwork room. A buckle’s face is larger than a coin’s, so fine detail is easier to keep. On a coin, the ship at sea on this buckle might shrink to a simple outline.
If the piece is for everyone, a coin is usually the better pick. If it’s for a few people who stay with the ship, choose the buckle. A buckle can also make a good commissioning gift or plank owner gift for that group.
What Changes When Artwork Moves to a Buckle
Moving artwork to a buckle can sharpen fine line work, lettering and textured areas such as water and knotwork. You can see this in the textured waves and corner knots on this buckle.
A buckle is rectangular, so a round crest usually needs a new layout. Our artists redraw the layout to fit the rectangle and work to keep the crest’s main details. You approve a digital proof (an on-screen preview of the final design) before production starts.
People usually see a buckle at an angle and in motion. Strong contrast between raised and recessed areas tends to stay readable in those conditions. On this military belt buckle, the metal ship sits against a colored background, which can help it stand out. Our manufacturing page explains how the metal is finished.
Buckles for Ships and Units
A custom ship belt buckle is a normal order for a crew. We’ve also made buckles for the USS Iowa and for Navy mustangs.
We build buckles from strong, high-quality materials so they can hold up to regular use. Each one is machined (cut and shaped by machine) and checked by our quality control team.
Browse more custom belt buckles in our gallery. If your crew wants something else to wear or use, let us know what you have in mind and we’ll suggest a format.
Order a Coin, a Buckle, or Both
Whether your crew wants a coin, a buckle or both, the artwork is free. Send your idea or your own files, and our artists will draft the design. Revise it as many times as you need, then approve the digital proof before anything is made. Shipping within the continental US is free, and rush production is available when a date is close.
We’re veteran-owned and registered in SAM.gov as an SDVOSB (service-disabled veteran-owned small business).
Let us know how many people you’re covering, since that number usually settles the format. If you’re still sorting through unit gift ideas, request a free quote and name the formats you’re considering.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should we order a challenge coin or a belt buckle?
In a challenge coin versus belt buckle decision, headcount usually settles it. Order a coin if the piece goes to everyone, and a buckle if it goes to a small group. Some units order both.
How much more does a belt buckle cost than a coin?
A buckle usually costs more per piece than a coin, often several times as much. The exact price can depend on size, colors, finish and quantity. Send us your headcount and artwork, and we’ll prepare a quote.
Can the same artwork be used on a coin and a buckle?
Yes, usually with some redrawing. A buckle is rectangular and larger, so our artists rearrange a round coin design to fit. Buckle artwork can hold finer detail, and we can simplify it for a coin.
What is the minimum order for custom belt buckles?
Belt buckles have their own minimum order, separate from the coin minimum. Tell us the headcount you’re covering, and we’ll confirm the current figure with your quote.
Can a belt buckle be engraved on the back?
Yes, in many cases. An engraved belt buckle like this one has detail on the reverse, and custom wording may fit there as well. Send us the text, and we’ll confirm what fits and show it on your digital proof.
Will a custom buckle fit a standard belt?
That depends on the buckle’s size and your belt’s width. Tell us which belt you plan to use, and the width if you know it. We’ll check the fit before production.
Do Navy ships order belt buckles?
Yes. We’ve made belt buckles with ship artwork, including the USS Patrick Gallagher and the USS Iowa. A Navy ship can start with a design idea or existing artwork.
Who usually receives a unit belt buckle?
Unit buckles usually go to a small group, such as a wardroom, a chiefs’ mess, a departing commanding officer or plank owners. Coins usually go to the wider crew.