Round, in the traditional challenge coin format, with a roped edge running the whole way around. The front carries the department’s badge. The back sets the State of Texas over a flat American flag with a thin blue line running through the middle of it. This Edinburgh police challenge coin follows the most established layout in law enforcement coin design and executes it cleanly.

The Thin Blue Line

The thin blue line is the most widely used device in American law enforcement coin design, and it is worth understanding both how it works visually and what it carries.

It is a strong graphic. A single horizontal band of color across an otherwise monochrome flag is high contrast, instantly readable and simple enough to strike cleanly at any size. Very few symbols are that efficient.

The meaning within the profession is specific. It represents law enforcement standing between order and disorder, and it is also closely associated with remembering officers killed in the line of duty.

It is also a contested symbol publicly. Outside the profession the device has been read in different ways in recent years, and some agencies have policies about its use on official items. That is worth checking before artwork rather than after a batch arrives.

And it has a flag etiquette dimension. Altering the colors of the flag is a departure from the Flag Code, which some departments have a view on. Agencies differ, and the decision belongs to the department rather than to the designer.

None of that is an argument against using it. It is an argument for the decision being made deliberately by someone with the authority to make it.

See also police challenge coins.

A State Outline Over a Flag

Layering a state shape over a flag is a standard law enforcement reverse, and it has one real design problem.

A flag is a busy field. Stripes and a star field fill the face with pattern, and anything placed on top needs strong separation or it disappears into the background. The standard fixes are to raise the state outline in relief so shadow separates it, to keep the flag muted while the state stays saturated, or to show the flag flat and simplified rather than complete and detailed.

Showing the flag flat, as this coin does, is the most effective of those. A flat flag has even, regular stripes rather than the varying widths of a waving one, which means a shape laid over it has a predictable background instead of an unpredictable one. It also strikes more cleanly, since a furled flag needs relief variation that competes with the element on top.

For a Texas coin specifically, the state outline is doing real work. Texas has one of the most recognizable state silhouettes in the country, which means it functions as a symbol rather than as a map.

The Roped Edge

A rope rim is the most common decorative edge in challenge coin production, and on a police coin it does something specific.

It signals tradition. A roped edge is the conventional treatment, which means it reads as established rather than designed. For an organization whose identity rests on continuity and authority, that is the correct signal, where an unusual edge treatment would read as fashionable.

It also closes the composition. A badge on the front and a flag on the back are both busy, and a defined rim gives each face a boundary that stops the content running to the edge.

The quality check is the join. A rope pattern repeats around the circumference, and the point where the pattern meets itself has to be invisible. An obvious seam is the common failure and it is immediately visible once noticed.

See edge and finish options.

Reproducing a Department Badge

The badge on the front is the element that needs the most care, for reasons covered by every police coin.

It is official insignia. Reproducing a department badge is a decision for the department, and written authorization should be in hand before artwork begins rather than sought afterward.

It is three dimensional in reality. A badge has levels and catches light in a particular way, so relief reproduces it far more faithfully than a flat rendering.

Its text will not all fit. Department name, number, rank. Lines that read on a badge worn at chest height become illegible when the badge is part of a coin face, so either the badge dominates the design or some text goes.

And everyone knows what it should look like. A badge rendered slightly wrong is spotted instantly by every officer who sees it, with no margin for approximation.

Order a Police Department Coin

Professional artwork is free with unlimited revisions, and nothing goes into production until you approve a digital proof. The challenge coin minimum is 50 pieces, standard production runs about 45 to 50 days after final artwork approval, rush production is available on many projects, and shipping within the continental United States is included. Embleholics is veteran-owned, SDVOSB and registered in SAM.gov.

Two suggestions. Get written approval for badge reproduction from the department before artwork starts, since the badge is official insignia. And if the design uses the thin blue line or an altered flag, confirm your agency’s position on it in advance, because some departments have a policy and finding out afterward is an expensive way to learn. Request a free quote to begin.

READY TO CREATE YOUR CUSTOM CHALLENGE COIN?

Whether you’re recognizing an achievement, celebrating a milestone, honoring service, or commemorating a special event, our professional artists will help create a custom challenge coin worthy of the moment.

✓ Free Professional Artwork
✓ Free Shipping
✓ 50 Coin Minimum
✓ Rush Production Available

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the thin blue line represent?

Within law enforcement it represents officers standing between order and disorder, and it is closely associated with remembering those killed in the line of duty.

Is the thin blue line a safe choice for a department coin?

It depends on the agency. The device has been read in different ways publicly in recent years and some departments have a policy on its use, so the question should be settled before artwork.

Is altering the flag’s colors a problem?

It is a departure from the Flag Code, and agencies differ on whether that matters for a coin. The decision belongs to the department rather than to whoever is organizing the order.

How do you keep a shape readable over a flag background?

Give it separation. Raise the shape in relief so shadow defines it, keep the flag muted against a saturated foreground, or show the flag flat and simplified rather than detailed.

Why show a flag flat rather than waving?

A flat flag has even regular stripes, so anything laid over it has a predictable background. A waving flag needs relief variation that competes with the element on top.

What does a roped edge signal?

Tradition. It is the conventional treatment, so it reads as established rather than designed, which suits an organization whose identity rests on continuity.

What can go wrong with a rope edge?

The join. The pattern repeats around the circumference and the point where it meets itself has to be invisible, or a visible seam shows on every coin in the batch.

Can a department badge go on a coin?

Yes, with the department’s written approval. It should be rendered in relief rather than flat, and some of its fine text usually has to come off to stay legible at coin size.